Josh

About

Username
Josh
Joined
Roles
Member

Comments

  • Sorry for disappearing for a few days (somehow, my RSS reader flaked and stopped indicating new posts to this thread)... A few posts back, CloudOfDust pointed to an apparent contradiction between two statements of mine, one of which seemed to a…
  • You've got a few options already - a simple way to do this would be to just tag everything for work with "work" and everything for home with "home", and set up smart collections for each. If, however, you're looking for more advanced functionality, …
  • CoD: "We cite them differently? The citation gives the information for the item and tells the reader where to find it. I don't see how it makes any difference to the bibliographic software whether the "container" is the original or a reproduction." …
  • On the "reproduced in" idea, it seems to me that the relationship between a journal article and its parent "Journal" item is different from that of a journal article and a book in which it's reproduced; this might just come down to a Benjamin-like n…
  • I'll also add one more point - I see the evolving taxonomy on the Trac page as Zotero-specific; as I see it, the primary agenda is to come up with something that we can implement in Zotero as soon as a few weeks from now, and to do so in a way that …
  • On the question of "ancillary" vs. other item types, I made a mistake in not being clear - this is a UI distinction, rather than an ontological one in the data model. From the data perspective, there's no difference between a journal issue and an ar…
  • Over the past day and a half, Sean and I hammered out a first proposal for a new data model that might address most of the concerns expressed here. I've gone ahead and updated the Trac wiki page, so take a look. It bears a strong similarity to Bruce…
  • Okay, let's take this over to http://forums.zotero.org/discussion/391/ and start having a discussion over hierarchical types...
  • Bruce, I totally agree. My point wasn't to say that only technical contributions matter, but rather about the historical development of open source culture - because the people who've been most involved have been fluent programmers, the two function…
  • There is an important point emerging here and elsewhere, that the broader philosophical discussions about the utility and affordances of research software are entangled with technical discussions of how those principles are actually implemented in c…
  • Actually, I've been meaning to join the list for a while, so thanks for the nudge!
  • I'd also chime in and say that there's potential for a more sophisticated utility to be built here, which would essentially allow drag-and-drop addition of references from within Zotero to Wilipedia pages (being edited from within the browser itself…