Oby

About

Username
Oby
Joined
Roles
Member

Comments

  • @adamsmith (Just a gentle reminder, as requested.)
  • Are you using Word? If so, a workaround would be, just before submission, (AND AFTER MAKING A COPY OF YOUR THESIS) to remove all the field codes in the document. Then you can find/replace the quotation marks in all footnotes and submit the thesis wi…
  • I submit on the 1st of March. So if it is in place a week before that, I'm a happy man ;-)
  • Sorry for nagging, but I just wondered whether there was any ETA/progress on the chapter pinpoints and the manuscripts item type. (Asking because my thesis will be submitted in a couple of weeks, and I am therefore charting out the things I need to…
  • Great! (PS: I guess polite argument on the internet is difficult, it's so easy to be misread. Good to hear I was not this time ;-) )
  • Thanks for fixing the bug of the missing "ch"! On "manuscipt", I see your points, but I still think the suggested change is compatible with both of them: 1) There would be no status quo change. There is no need to touch the output of "Report" in O…
  • I also came across a small bug in the OSCOLA style today; pinpoint citations to chapters are not rendering correctly on subsequent cites. To reproduce: cite a book in Libreoffice, choosing "chapter" from the drop-down menu and entering the chapter …
  • Fantastic news, thanks for taking the time to answer! I will just decline the upgrade until the thesis is submitted, as it is likely to be a for a period of a couple of weeks (provided that Zotero 5.0 releases before March, that is).
  • @adamsmith : Report appears to give the right output, if the research papers series is given in the "Report Type" field, and the number in the "Report number" field. The output is as follows: John M Finnis, ‘On Public Reason’ (2006) Oxford Legal Stu…
  • @LiborA : That's exactly the kind of think I fear, and why I don't intend to upgrade. But my question remains: Will we be prompted for the upgrade? Or will the upgrade be automatic? If the latter is the case: can I do anything to "block" the upgrad…
  • I have another suggestion for "low-hanging fruit"-improvement to OSCOLA; correct styling of working papers. This is what the OSCOLA manual (4th edn) says about such papers: Working papers may be available online on institution websites and on sites…
  • One question: to what extent will the upgrade to 5.0 be forced on the user (i.e. happen automatically)? I am not afraid of change, and am very much looking forward to 5.0 but, as I am finishing my PhD in February/March, my inner "if it ain't broke,…
  • Great work, and well documented!
  • Great news! Just tested it, and it looks perfect now. Here is the exact output before/after the update: Before: Alexandros Tsadiras, ‘The Ombudsman’, EU Administrative Law (2nd edn, OUP 2012) 754. After: Alexandros Tsadiras, ‘The Ombudsman’ in Pa…
  • (Before I begin, let me thank you adamsmith for your latest post. I did not realize that the item type was the culpit.) I came across a peculiar form of book chapter today, namely a chapter by one author in what is (apart from that chapter) a monog…
  • Today I noticed that conference papers are not rendered correctly in OSCOLA. At present I get the following when using the word plugin or "copy to clipboard" function on a item with all necessary metadata: Motoyo Kamiya, ‘A Study of Formal Relations…
  • I don't have a concrete example of a book at hand now (away from the office), but as you can see the OUP house style allows for both US and UK styles when writing, with their respective quotation mark standards: https://global.oup.com/academic/autho…
  • @fbennett: The thing is that OSCOLA is strictly a referencing style. See the style guide, which is very meager, which has nothing to say about the style of quotation marks or anything else outside the references themselves: https://www.law.ox.ac.uk/…
  • Thanks for the quick and useful clarification! I only have one thing to add, to help others: If we are first to make custom alterations to the style, another way of achieving this would be to omit the final period. If so, it would be possible to ad…
  • Of course, if Juris-M style case support (including multiple jurisdictions) is implemented, the primary case would be moot. And I see the point of keeping things simple on the word processor plugin change. I even agree that ibid is not too problemat…
  • For case citations two things are missing: First, proper citation formats (MLZ/Juris-M seems to have that working, though, but I prefer to use the official client). Second, the need for multiple bibliographies - one for each category of sources (cas…
  • I don't think you quite got my point. Look very closely at the example I provided and read the text afterwords carefully. To clarify even more, here is a screenshot showing a similar example (grey shading = Zotero field), with the edit citation win…
  • That's what I thought. But maybe it will be rectified in Zotero's core some time. Perhaps it should be added to GitHub as an enhancement request? Your suggested solution would work. I might just do that as part of the finalization process (but that…
  • I just came across another quirk in the OSCOLA style (for regular Zotero, not MLZ), specifically how it refers back to previous footnotes in Libreoffice. This works very well for the normal case where the footnote numbers run continously throughou…
  • Adamsmith: I have two suggested enhancements for OSCOLA when it comes to citation of secondary sources. Hope you have time to take a look at them - would love to help out myself, but the style has become so complex that I can't understand most of th…
  • I have brought this up as a feature request for Libreoffice, and had it accepted. If you wish to see this feature implemented in Libreoffice, please help out here: https://bugs.freedesktop.org/show_bug.cgi?id=80786 Also, it was suggested as a worka…
  • A minor bug: ibid is capitalized, which according to OSCOLA 4th ed it should not. Example of present behavior (footnote): "Ibid 492 and 507–512."
  • Yes, this is what I was referring to. I though it might be possible to drop the URL if the # Pages field in Zotero for a book was populated in order to tackle this problem. Anyway, as a workaround I'll just move the URL to the "extras" field for th…
  • 1) Here is one example of a book that has a page range of 1-393 in the # Pages field in Zotero, but nevertheless there is still an URL added tot he citation (using square brackets instead of "
  • Any progress on fixing this bug?