Upgrade Storagedunning
About
- Username
- dunning
- Joined
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
The problem is deciding how to implement CMOS 14.65: ‘If in doubt whether a particular periodical is better treated as a journal or as a magazine, use journal form if the volume number is easily located, magazine form if it is not.’ There are exampl…
-
@bwiernik The host of a podcast is consistently labeled as such in both Chicago (14.168) and MLA (examples at the end of the handbook).
-
@dstillman Is there a central list somewhere of variables that need to be added as Zotero fields and corrections to mappings? I tried submitting a pull request for the ‘podcaster’ problem several months ago but I’m not sure it was the right place: …
-
Zotero predates CSL, meaning that its fields occasionally do not correspond to the correct variable, and of course many necessary variables are missing a field. For example, Zotero's 'director' on films previously used the CSL author rather than dir…
-
@aarblaster Thanks for catching that; I've fixed it in a forthcoming update.
-
@jvoros See the Buolamwini example in the Quick Guide for placing the episode name of a broadcast before the programme title without an episode number: https://www.chicagomanualofstyle.org/tools_citationguide/citation-guide-1.html#cg-interview
-
@jvoros They seem to be treating a broadcast as something in between a serial publication and a multivolume monographic work. Compare MHRA 7.8 for a similar hybrid. I've written CMOS and hope that we'll find out the answer in a month or two.
-
@jvoros There are no examples of broadcast episodes in CMOS without an episode number, so I chose to use the reversed format only if there is both a title and episode number. I have absolutely no idea which approach is correct, but I'll write CMOS t…
-
@jvoros You're seeing three unrelated bugs: Zotero incorrectly maps its 'podcaster' field to CSL author rather than host; BetterBibTeX is overriding an author on any film/broadcast items (this isn't specific to podcasts) as director to fix Zotero's…
-
It really ought to work. You could perhaps try switching to something similar such as MHRA style, then back to Chicago with British English?
-
If you're technically inclined, it's possible to create multiple bibliographies using pandoc: https://github.com/pandoc-ext/multibib This approach relies on creating multiple bibliography files, but it's trivial to modify this filter to separate b…
-
@erauchway I fixed this bug a couple of weeks ago, but it is awaiting review. In the meantime, you can also fix this by adding the archive-place and/or archive_collection fields to Extra, as described here: https://forums.zotero.org/discussion/comm…
-
@jvoros I suspect that you're encountering the difference in pandoc versus citeproc-js (the citation processor in Zotero) in the interpretation of languages. Pandoc follows the CSL specification strictly, which states that the value of language shou…
-
You can change the citation language (in Document Preferences within the Zotero plugin for Word) without unlinking the citations, just as you can switch to any style. Shortened notes are now author–title by default in the 18th edition of Chicago. T…
-
Chicago style doesn’t, to my knowledge, specify a sort order for multiple references within a citation. If I’ve missed something, please do point me to the relevant section.
-
This is an issue in pandoc: https://github.com/jgm/citeproc/issues/166 The idea here is to meet the requirement in Chicago (CMOS 14.143–54), and many other styles, for complex locators that do not require a label. I wonder however whether the nume…
-
@jvoros Does it fix the problem if you remove the line from the CSL file?
-
Oxford style is defined in New Hart's Rules or the Oxford Style Manual. See here for their approach to the author–date (a.k.a. Harvard) system: https://archive.org/details/oxfordstylemanua0000unse/page/566/ https://archive.org/details/newhartsrule…
-
@tonylominac Mendeley and RefWorks use the same CSL styles as Zotero. Turabian 8th edition is based on Chicago 16th edition and the styles will give you the same results. It’s very common for schools to specify older editions, not because they want…
-
@rudyleon Thanks for following up on that. The Chicago editors typically respond to queries within a month. The styles follow official guidance as closely as the software allows; I’m happy to make adjustments if my interpretation is inaccurate.
-
@rudyleon CSL styles cannot automatically detect whether or not a document includes a bibliography. To meet the requirements of CMOS 13.23, use one of the Chicago notes without bibliography options in the Zotero styles repository.
-
MHRA provides access dates even with items that have an issue date.
-
@siobhan.hayes I'm glad that you have a solution; I am also reworking New Hart's Rules and need to develop a way to embed OSCOLA in this already, so I will probably add the rules to MHRA as well.
-
The correction is included here: https://github.com/citation-style-language/styles/pull/7679 This needs to be reviewed before being included in Zotero. Everyone contributing to the CSL project is a volunteer, so it's hard to predict how long this …
-
1. See CMOS 14.114 for the usage of 'unpublished manuscript', which will only appear if the citation lists no means of accessing a manuscript. In your example, 'BAV' should be in the Archive field and the shelfmark, 'Reg. Lat. 548', should be in the…
-
A Zotero 'code number' is mapped to a volume number, which MHRA displays as Roman numerals, but it's only meant to do this with a numeric value. The display you are seeing looks to be a bug in the citation processor (citeproc-js). As there are no e…
-
It looks as if this is a problem with the website translator. I can confirm that if I visit this page and save the article to Zotero, 32 is correctly added as the issue, but also 'Number: 32' appears in the Extra field: https://iupress.istanbul.edu…
-
Adding an approximate date is definitely be the way to go. The only problem is that I assumed that journals could not have an uncertain date and left out the processing for this. I will be submitting a fix momentarily! Otherwise, 'forthcoming' will…
-
To be more precise, the styles for the 18th edition use the CSL 'forthcoming' term if a journal article has a volume/issue/supplement number and no issue date, page range, or article number. If anyone can think of situations in which one would want …
-
This is intentional, as I had assumed that any journal article without a date must be forthcoming, following examples in the official manual. In what situation would one have a published journal article without a known date? This behaviour only app…