Upgrade Storagedunning
About
- Username
- dunning
- Joined
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
Yes, it looks as if the 16th edition of the Chicago styles handle the section field as part of the locator for newspapers, but this is a misinterpretation of the CSL specification, which specifically indicates that 'section' is to be used for a name…
-
The Section field is for the name of a department or column (e.g. Opinion) rather than a location. Cf. https://forums.zotero.org/discussion/comment/499246#Comment_499246
-
If you're submitting to a journal with a public style sheet/author instructions, let us know which one and we'll ensure there is a Chicago style configured for it. If you definitely need the place of publication with Chicago, use one of the 'classi…
-
MHRA calls for title-only abbreviated references: https://www.mhra.org.uk/style/chapter7.html#section_7_12 Edit: I now think that MHRA 7.12 is showing specific situations that CSL mostly cannot replicate, rather than indicating a bar on showing ed…
-
@klleach This is the same problem as mentioned above for which I submitted a correction in September, but it is still waiting for @bwiernik or @adamsmith to review it.
-
Are you able to give a more specific example? If you want a particular item to be cited under a name rather than a title, you can simply add an author, editor, translator, or composer. If none of these is available, the style substitutes the title …
-
The main OUP citation style is found in New Hart's Rules: The Oxford Style Guide: https://www.zotero.org/styles?q=oxford style Previously, there was also an OUP modification of the Chicago Manual of Style in the repository, but they have now switc…
-
Brilliant: the Chicago 17th/18th edition styles should be robust. That MLA 6th edition notes style was a variant for a specific journal that has now thankfully switched to official MLA style. For other notes styles with full bibliographical details,…
-
This style has been superseded and I think it ought to be deleted from the repository. Is there a specific publication calling for this style?
-
Great! MHRA does take a slightly different approach here; it’s designed around the needs of modern languages and literature research.
-
I use a group library of 26,213 items with no performance issues.
-
This is the MLA container 2; put the title of the website in the Library Catalogue field. This will only display if there is also a URL or DOI.
-
Thank you for reporting this. There is an example of the developer appearing in the author position in the current print edition of the MLA Handbook, but that must have been an error, since it has been removed in the digital version. I've now adjust…
-
I'm very glad to hear that MHRA works for you. In response to your request, I've proposed variants for Chicago that always display access dates, but I have no idea how long it will take before they are published in the styles repository: https://gi…
-
Yes, the rules on what a bibliography is to include are scattered across about a dozen sections. You’ll find citations if you look at the CSL code. Logically however full notes can stand on their own, as in a journal article, whilst the parenthetica…
-
I do mean the style's treatment of composer. Right now it is treating a composer's name as the primary author in all circumstances. It seems to me that the CMOS18 14.165 example of a film cited under a composer's name works about as well as an audio…
-
When using Chicago notes, the Manual advises listing only items in the bibliography that the reader can follow up, omitting unpublished manuscripts, events, personal correspondence, presentations, etc. Unpublished/inaccessible items appear in notes …
-
Yes, that is exactly how shortened notes continues to work in the 18th edition; try the style called Chicago Manual of Style 18th edition (shortened notes and bibliography, classic variants). If your publisher has the style sheet on their website, …
-
I don't know where one could put a choreographer; the CSL specification gives a full list of supported name types. It's true that 'music by' should be covered by a composer. Interestingly a similar question has also just come up in another thread: …
-
@adamsmith Possibly the composer could display as a primary creator only with audio recordings and musical scores?
-
Citing an entire periodical volume is usually done in the case of a supplement or special issue on a certain theme, normally with its own title and editor, such as these examples from CMOS 14.77–78: https://www.zotero.org/groups/2205533/items/ZZYXK…
-
Your professor might be thinking of MHRA style, which is more common than Chicago in the UK and always displays the access date for URLs. The easiest option might be to use that style guide. CMOS 13.15 makes it an option to record access dates for …
-
Does the shortened notes and bibliography, classic variants option for the 18th edition meet your needs? This carries forward options from earlier editions such as the place of publication and chapter page numbers that are no longer the default choi…
-
The performance type is supported in APA, Chicago, MHRA, and styles that I've nearly finished for New Hart's Rules. This is how I encoded the example in CMOS18 14.166: https://www.zotero.org/groups/2205533/items/N3I33ZLM
-
That's an interesting case. The composer always takes priority to cover the example of a filmed performance in CMOS18 14.165 (plus similar examples in APA and MHRA). Might it work if you add your other names as generic contributors?
-
I've just checked the 17th edition (which is the basis of Turabian 9th); it looks as if this rule is new in the 18th edition, but they didn't document it as such in the What's New list. I've added a fix here: https://github.com/citation-style-langu…
-
Unpublished presentations usually do not appear in the bibliography; see the Chicago Manual of Style, sect. 14.115: To cite a paper or poster presented at a meeting, add information about sponsorship, location (if applicable), and date of the meetin…
-
Unfortunately the styles can only detect whether or not a certain variable is present, and cannot leave out information based on its value.
-
Pandoc (and anything based on it, such as Quarto or Zelltr) will automatically link titles in a bibliography when using a style that does not display a URL. There are variants of Chicago, MHRA, and MLA in the styles repository that do this. https:/…
-
It is possible that your instructors simply haven't noticed this detail. While it is explicit in both Chicago and Turabian that not every citation needs a corresponding bibliography entry, you can see from the list of references in my last post that…