Style Request Kunstgeschichte / Kunstwissenschaft (German)
Hi.
I have tried several styles but none of them is even similar to the citation standards that are common in art historical papers and publications, although I have seen many simlar styles in books.
Important: This is not the citation style of one specific journal or publisher.
Examples:
Campbell, Pedersen 2007
Campbell, Pedersen 2007
Campbell, John L.; Pedersen, Ove K.: The varieties of capitalism and hybrid success, in: Comparative Political Studies, 40 (2007), 3, S. 307–332, doi:10.1177/0010414006286542 (abgerufen am 1.1.2016).
Mares 2001
Mares 2001
Mares, Isabela: Firms and the welfare state. When, why, and how does social policy matter to employers? in: Hall, Peter Arthur; Soskice, Diane (Hrsg.): Varieties of capitalism. The institutional foundations of comparative advantage, New York 2001, S. 184–213.
Links to freely available online papers:
http://www.kunstgeschichte-ejournal.net/413/1/3_Fischer_Kennerschaft_beiHieronymus_Bosch_KF_fertig.pdf
http://www.kunstgeschichte-ejournal.net/419/1/Kopie_und_Kennerschaft_-_%C3%9Cber_eine_k%C3%BCnstlerische_Praxis_und_ihre_Bedeutung_f%C3%BCr_die_Erforschung_der_fl%C3%A4mischen_Buchmalerei_Endfassung_LQ.pdf
http://digi.ub.uni-heidelberg.de/diglit/buettner2000
online style documentation:
http://www.kunstgeschichte-ejournal.net/deposit/guidelines.html
Important: exhibition catalogues are abbreviated as follows:
*Place of the exhibition* *year*
e.g.: London 2010
Thank you in advance
Anna
I have tried several styles but none of them is even similar to the citation standards that are common in art historical papers and publications, although I have seen many simlar styles in books.
Important: This is not the citation style of one specific journal or publisher.
Examples:
Campbell, Pedersen 2007
Campbell, Pedersen 2007
Campbell, John L.; Pedersen, Ove K.: The varieties of capitalism and hybrid success, in: Comparative Political Studies, 40 (2007), 3, S. 307–332, doi:10.1177/0010414006286542 (abgerufen am 1.1.2016).
Mares 2001
Mares 2001
Mares, Isabela: Firms and the welfare state. When, why, and how does social policy matter to employers? in: Hall, Peter Arthur; Soskice, Diane (Hrsg.): Varieties of capitalism. The institutional foundations of comparative advantage, New York 2001, S. 184–213.
Links to freely available online papers:
http://www.kunstgeschichte-ejournal.net/413/1/3_Fischer_Kennerschaft_beiHieronymus_Bosch_KF_fertig.pdf
http://www.kunstgeschichte-ejournal.net/419/1/Kopie_und_Kennerschaft_-_%C3%9Cber_eine_k%C3%BCnstlerische_Praxis_und_ihre_Bedeutung_f%C3%BCr_die_Erforschung_der_fl%C3%A4mischen_Buchmalerei_Endfassung_LQ.pdf
http://digi.ub.uni-heidelberg.de/diglit/buettner2000
online style documentation:
http://www.kunstgeschichte-ejournal.net/deposit/guidelines.html
Important: exhibition catalogues are abbreviated as follows:
*Place of the exhibition* *year*
e.g.: London 2010
Thank you in advance
Anna
https://www.zotero.org/styles?q=Infoclio%20%28German%20-%20Switzerland%29
or
https://www.zotero.org/styles?q=Geistes-%20und%20Kulturwissenschaften%20%28Heilmann%29%20%28German%29
are broadly similar. Beyond that, see
https://www.zotero.org/support/dev/citation_styles/style_editing_step-by-step
for editing styles
I have tried both styles you suggested. They are a bit similar, but not very. The abbreviations do not match - I need the same abbreviations as in CMOS or ISO 690 (preferably ISO 690), they are way too long, especially for edited books (except for exhibition cataolgues).
abbreviations/short tiltes should look like this:
*author(s)* or *editor(s)* or *place* (with exhibition/museum catalogues) + *year*
I have tried editing zotero citation styles but I am afraid that this task is way too difficult for me.
Anyway thanks for the anawer.
Maybe @zuphilip is more motivated to take this, he's particularly interested in German styles. For me this is very low priority, to be honest.
Well acually infoclio is useful for generating bibliographies, which is the bigger part of the work. Inserting the citations "manually" is not a big deal.
I have not invented the art historical citation standards, I whish they were more similar to ISO 690 or CMOS, but I and many other colleagues must nevertheless respect them. I mean I cannot change them, unfortunately, since I am not the editor of a journal or so.
But I think there is neither an English art history citation style for zotero. The English style is quite similar to the German: ed. or eds. instead of Hrsg. and p. or nothing instead of S. (abbreviation page numbers)
I would not mind an English art history citation style for zotero at all. Maybe it is easier to create the English style first and then modify it? Are there any English styles that are similar to "Infoclio" or "Geistes- und Kulturwissenschaften"? (i. e. year at the end and the publisher's name is not mentioned, only the city)
BTW: I guess I mean subsequent citations by abbreaviations or short titles, but the thing is that in art historical publications you do not mention the title of a cited publication at all in the text, only in the bibliography. But it is the same with ISO 690 and CMOS.
<3> @adamsmith: How are exhibition catalogues treated in Zotero? I would just enter them as normal books and maybe ajdust the title a little. Anything else one should do? Well, actually the last example in the style guide illustrate that the catalogues are treated as normal books. Anyway, I am not sure if we _can_ technically treat catalogues differently...
Ok, that is my mistake. The Journal actually does not want bibliographies, but please make the style for Zotero with bibliography.
Please treat exhibition or museum catalogues as edited books (editors + year), if "city + year" is not possible.
I have also tried the Kritische Ausgabe. I guess its a good start but Geistes- und Kulturwissenschaften or Infoclio are not bad either.
The trouble is that it is hard to find guidelines in the internet since there are not many online journals, the kunstgeschichteejournal is maybe not the ideal example but the only thing I know.
The book by Nils Büttner does not contain guidelines but it is a better example to start with, so have a good look at that.
The book style would be problematic because currently (I guess) it would not even be accepted in the repo: https://github.com/citation-style-language/styles/wiki/Criteria-for-Accepting-Styles
Moreover, I don't understand the book style really; because besides from normal author-date it uses also e.g. However, I can try to find some time to do the style for the journal. By default we include a bibliography, even when the style don't ask for one. From there it might be easy for you to create your own preferred style by changing the inline citation slightly.
"Vgl. Anm. 23" means "vergleiche Anmerkung 23" (compare/see note 23) - just ignore this, this should be a normal author-date-citation, it is a mistake
It would be nice if you could do the style for the journal eventually.
How do I change the inline citation?
Well. I hope you understand what I mean. I guess it should be some kind of an author-date-style.
I think this link should be useful, too:
http://www.riha-journal.org/about/for-authors/style-guide
I hope you can see what all these styles have in common, I think they are quite similar. The differences do not really matter (e. g. whether there is a a dot, a comma or a slash, or if cagalogues are abbreviated with city + year or editors + year)
Anyway thank you in advance.
That journal exists much longer then all the others you mentioned and the citation style seems also to be better documented.
I think that most of the others could be derived quite easily from here. @blitzgneisserin: However, it seems that you choose another way now to continue.
@adamsmith: Okay, but here it was a different case (Sp. as well as Bd. are part of the locator), because the full reference is: I guess the missing year might just be an error in endnote (as well as the forward reference from note 18 to note 23 might just be an error in the book.)
Well, I guess I kind of got unpatient :), so I created a style myself. But I learned something by creating it...
There is one thing though: maybe we should rename the style because there is another "Zeitschrift für Kunstgeschichte" which is the actual Zeitschrift für Kunstgeschichte:
http://www.deutscherkunstverlag.de/buch/zeitschriften/zeitschrift-fuer-kunstgeschichte/
This is a different journal. It is not the same as the ejournal Kunstgeschichte.
BTW: my new style which is derived from Infoclio is almost perfect now, I am just struggling with one or two more things, so you might want to have a look at the new discussion.
This citation style don't use any labels for the locator (such as "S.") which is different from citation style for the "Kunstgeschichte" journal. Moreover, it uses italics and I guess some other (small) differences.
However, I also see this in the code:
"the information for exhibition catalogues should be entered in the field collection-title; locators may use the word "here" or "hier" in front of the page refering to which must be entered individually (the style outputs the locator as it is entered w/o any label or additional text)."
What is "collection-title" in German? I do not find this field in my German Zotero. Maybe "Archiv"?
If the entry-type is book-chapter, zotero does this:
Stephan Kemperdick, I tableau à II hysseoires - ein Bild mit zwei Flügeln: wandelbare und nicht wandelbare Bildensembles in der Zeit Rogier van der Weydens, in: Stephan Kemperdick und Jochen Sander (Hrsg.) Der Meister von Flémalle und Rogier van der Weyden, Ostfildern 2008, 1–10.
Instead of:
Stephan Kemperdick, I tableau à II hysseoires - ein Bild mit zwei Flügeln: wandelbare und nicht wandelbare Bildensembles in der Zeit Rogier van der Weydens, in: Der Meister von Flémalle und Rogier van der Weyden, hg. von Stephan Kemperdick, Jochen Sander, Ostfildern 2008, 1–10.
(I really feel so bad for criticizing but to err is human :) )
But the second part of the entry should look the same as the entry for edited books.
Currently, the bibliography looks like this:
Stephan Kemperdick, I tableau à II hysseoires - ein Bild mit zwei Flügeln: wandelbare und nicht wandelbare Bildensembles in der Zeit Rogier van der Weydens, in: Stephan Kemperdick und Jochen Sander (Hrsg.) Der Meister von Flémalle und Rogier van der Weyden, Ostfildern 2008, 1–10.
Der Meister von Flémalle und Rogier van der Weyden, hg. von Stephan Kemperdick, Jochen Sander, Ostfildern 2008.
I mean you are right, the mistake is not there where I thought.
I will/would probably do the correction myself eventually if none else does it, but I think it is not easy.
However, the "Hrsg." is wrong and a comma is missing, right?
Maybe someone should contact the editors and ask them how they want it because this is obviously a mistake in the stylesheet?
I will write an email to the Redaktion and ask for clarification about the order or editors and book title.
I am still wondering a little though why you chose the "Zeitschrift" für Kunstgeschichte". It was actually a good choice because it is one of the most respected art historical journals.
Unfortunately there is no style guide or stylesheet for the "Kunstchronik" on the internet.
Stephan Kemperdick, I tableau à II hysseoires - ein Bild mit zwei Flügeln: wandelbare und nicht wandelbare Bildensembles in der Zeit Rogier van der Weydens, in: Der Meister von Flémalle und Rogier van der Weyden hg. von Stephan Kemperdick, Jochen Sander, Ostfildern 2008, 1–10.
Ich find die Stelle im Code nicht.