term name="author" in CSL 1.0

dittaeva
I've been tweaking the nn-NO and nb-NO locales for CSL 1.0 and found that none of the localizations have translated/specified anything for <term name="author">.

Why is that?
  • bdarcus
    Because it's never been needed. Author is effectively understood in all styles I've ever heard of to be the default, implicit role, and only other roles get explicitly annotated.
  • dittaeva
    Ah, of course, thanks. But then at least it doesn't hurt to translate it either :)
  • RintzeRintze
    edited October 31, 2010
    But then at least it doesn't hurt to translate it either
    It can hurt. Adding a translation for the "author" term for e.g. English could result in "Doe (author)" and "Smith (editor)" instead of "Doe" and "Smith (editor)". The former is almost never desirable.
  • ajlyon
    @Rintze:
    That sounds like a problem in the way that CSL is interpreted-- why should the rendering or non-rendering of creator roles depend on whether the appropriate terms are defined in the localization files?
  • RintzeRintze
    Without having checked the xbiblio mailing list archives, my guess is that the current implementation was based on the assumption that the use of an author label might be subject to localization (although that doesn't appear to be the case for styles written so far).
  • bdarcus
    Well, CSL has some magic for dealing with roles, and part of that magic is based on the assumption I mention above. Otherwise, the styles would be a fair bit more complex.

This is an old discussion that has not been active in a long time. Instead of commenting here, you should start a new discussion. If you think the content of this discussion is still relevant, you can link to it from your new discussion.