Style error: Journal of Structural Geology

jocarv2015

CSL inputs citations in alphabetical order and then by date but Journal requires first by date and then by author: "Sort multiple citations in the text chronologically and then alphabetically, separate them by a semi-colon e.g. (Sprunt and Nur, 1976; Hickman and Evans, 1995; Lehner, 1995)."
With my zotero I have: ... lateMiocene (Casas Sainz and Faccenna, 2001; Ribeiro et al., 1990; Srivastava et al., 1990).

damnation

This style is dependent on elsevier-harvard.csl, which first sorts alphabetically and the crhonologically.
@adamsmith, can you advise if we should make this an independent style? Style guide here: https://www.elsevier.com/journals/journal-of-structural-geology/0191-8141/guide-for-authors (this style guide doesn't mention CSL).

jocarv2015

Thank You for your reply.
I am not an expert on this but by tentative and error I changed the style to a personnel one and that solved de problem. But now I see that there are other differences between Zotero CSL and the required formatation for the Elsevier Journ. Struct. Geology. At least I saw differences on the bibliographic listing for Maps (editor and edition number not mentioned) and for Thesis (Zotero puts "Ph.D. Thesis" between brackets). I don't know how to change it.
So I believe that you should make an independent style for this Journal.

adamsmith

@damnation --yes, this doesn't look very much like an Elsevier standard to me at all (e.g. the additional geological format, ordering, lack of italics, full journal names). Make it independent.

damnation

@jocarv2015
Made a first quick draft. Can you let me know if it needs any more changes? https://github.com/citation-style-language/styles/pull/2603

jocarv2015

Where do I find a link to the respective csl file?

adamsmith

The CSL is here: https://github.com/damnation333/styles/raw/20dccdc770733426551323be8f316679d5ac47af/journal-of-structural-geology.csl (right-click --> save link as) Alternatively you can wait until we have reviewed it & the updated version appears on zotero.org/styles We try to do this within 48hs if possible. Advantage of checking out the style now is that you can report back any issues remaining to damnation.

jocarv2015

Thank you. I'll try and let you know

jocarv2015

A Fast inspection gives me some issues:
- Inline citations not according to date and then author (xxxxxx (Carvalho, 2013; Carvalho et al., 2008; Kulatilake and Wu, 1984)). According to Elsevier should be (Kulatilake and Wu, 1984; Carvalho et al., 2008; Carvalho, 2013)

- Bibliographic issues:
- In a PhD thesis: After de title of thesis is missing a dot and a space before "Ph. D. Thesis ....". And shoyld be Ph.D. instead of Ph. D.
- In edited book: missing a dot before "In: Atksinson, B.K. (Ed) ....". And missing also the number of pages at the end
- In edited book with more than one editor the number of pages is not missing
- For maps is missing the scale and the Editor

That is all for now

adamsmith

("And shoyld be Ph.D. instead of Ph. D." -- that one you need to fix in the data. The style just prints the type field).

jocarv2015

Ooops, you are right. My mistake!

damnation

Switched sorting to ascending instead of descending (issue date).
Fixed the dot.
Maps: can you give an example citation i can import to Zotero so i can test that?

jocarv2015

For maps:
This is the example presented in Instructions for authors:
Albee, H.F., Cullins, H.L., 1975. Geologic map of the Alpine Quadrangle, Bonneville County, Idaho, and Lincoln County Wyoming. United States Geological Survey Geologic Quadrangle Map GQ-1259, scale 1:24,000

But it is very US oriented. So, it will be better like this (and I believe Elsevier will agree with it):
Author, year. Map title. Series (if available), scale. Editor, edition
Example: AAAAA, J., BBBBBBB, D., 2016. Folha 27-B Tomar. Carta Geológica de Portugal, escala 1:50000, Instituto Geológico e Mineiro, 2ª edição

adamsmith

I'm pretty sure this should be "Publisher, edition" not "Editor, edition" (The Portuguese "editor" translates to English "publisher")

jocarv2015

You're right again!

damnation

Map added. Have a look what you think.

jocarv2015

Please send me the link to download

damnation

The link hasn't changed.

adamsmith

https://raw.githubusercontent.com/damnation333/styles/048c1d0165f7bda71945f585e0511ebcf365cd37/journal-of-structural-geology.csl

adamsmith

(@damnation the raw links do change by commit, unless you get them not from the pull request but by going to the branch in your github fork, which I didn't do above out of convenience)

jocarv2015

For a map, my data is:
Title: Folha 27-A Vila Nova de Ourém
Author: Manuppela, G. and 3 others
Scale: 1:50000
Series Title: Carta Geológica de Portugal
Edition: 2ª
Local: Lisboa
Publisher ((in Portuguese "Editora"): Instituto Geológico e Mineiro
Date: 1998

It appears wrongly as: Manuppella, G., Barbosa, B., Machado, S., Carvalho, J., 1998. Folha 27-A Vila Nova de Ourém, Carta Geológica de Portugal à escala 1:50000, 2a ed. Carta Geológica de Portugal1:50000, Instituto Geológico e Mineiro, Lisboa, 2a. ed.

jocarv2015

For Ph.D. it still appears as: "... da atividade extrativaPh.D. thesis. Univers..."
I mean, no dot and no space before Ph.D.

adamsmith

The record must say "Carta Geológica de Portugal à escala 1:50000" somewhere (type?) I don't see how the style could add the "à escala 1:50000" given that it's in English.

adamsmith

@damnation note that there is a CSL term for "scale" that you could use here.

jocarv2015

I believe that based on the input data the record could be:
authors, date. Folha 27-A Vila Nova de Ourém, Carta Geológica de Portugal, 1:50000, Instituto Geológico e Mineiro, Lisboa, 2a. ed.

damnation

@jocarv2015
Check out the style up on the repository.