Upgrade Storagedisambiguating between different authors and editors
I have found two problems with the
<option name="disambiguate-add-year-suffix" value="true"/>
citation option.
Firstly, it doesn't disambiguate between the same name in author field and the editor field, when the editor's name is substituting for the author. This is quite a common occurrence. For example, Smith is the editor of a book published in 2004 and also had a chapter in that book. I want to cite both the book and the chapter, but the citation and the bibliography do not have a year suffix.
This could be solved by a disambiguation option that worked with the author-short macro, in which the editor's name is substituted for a citation with no author.
Secondly, it doesn't disambiguate between two citations with no dates by the same author.
This seems to be true of all the available author-date styles, so the problem would seem to be in the CSL citation option above.
Is anyone able to provide a solution. It would help to fix all the existing author-date styles on Zotero.
<option name="disambiguate-add-year-suffix" value="true"/>
citation option.
Firstly, it doesn't disambiguate between the same name in author field and the editor field, when the editor's name is substituting for the author. This is quite a common occurrence. For example, Smith is the editor of a book published in 2004 and also had a chapter in that book. I want to cite both the book and the chapter, but the citation and the bibliography do not have a year suffix.
This could be solved by a disambiguation option that worked with the author-short macro, in which the editor's name is substituted for a citation with no author.
Secondly, it doesn't disambiguate between two citations with no dates by the same author.
This seems to be true of all the available author-date styles, so the problem would seem to be in the CSL citation option above.
Is anyone able to provide a solution. It would help to fix all the existing author-date styles on Zotero.
Is there any news on this problem since the last post on this thread? Any workaround other than manually adding the disambiguation?
--------example------
(Greco and Stenner 2008, 2008) (Aminzade and McAdam 2002, 2002)
Aminzade, Ron, and Doug McAdam, eds. 2002. Special Issue on Emotions and Contentious Politics, Mobilization: An International Journal 7(2).
Aminzade, Ron, and Doug McAdam. 2002. “Emotions and contentious politics.” Mobilization: An International Quarterly 7(2): 107-109.
Greco, Monica, and Paul Stenner, eds. 2008. Emotions: A Reader. London, New York: Routledge.
Greco, Monica, and Paul Stenner. 2008. “Introduction: Emotion and Social Science.” In Emotions: A Social Science Reader, eds. Monica Greco and Paul Stenner. London, New York: Routledge, p. 1-21.
While it's not any immediate help, the new Zotero CSL citation formatter that I am working on will handle the first case (disambiguation based on substituted names) correctly. The second case will also be handled as James desires, although it might look a little odd typographically.
Frank Bennett