Chapter deposited on arXiv is saved as book

b0c5
When I try to save this: https://arxiv.org/abs/1206.1901, it gets saved into Zotero as a book.

I think it should be saved as preprint, like all things from arXiv (even if they are a deposit from something else).
  • adamsmith
    No, we're importing the final publications on purpose where they exist, and I think that's the right approach (some people will disagree, but I think more often than not that's correct). The problem here is that the linked DOI is for the book instead of the chapter -- the chapter does have it's own DOI, but T&F has made a giant mess of that: 10.1201/b10905-6 has the right metadata (https://search.crossref.org/search/works?q=10.1201/b10905-6&from_ui=yes but 10.1201/b10905-10 is linking to the right place.

    You _can_ import the 'preprint' metadata by right-clicking on the Save to Zotero icon, selecting DOI and then the chapter title: currently that imports as a journal article because we don't handle preprints from Datacite properly, but that's something we'll actually fix, hopefully in the near future.
  • b0c5
    edited January 11, 2024
    > No, we're importing the final publications on purpose where they exist, and I think that's the right approach (some people will disagree, but I think more often than not that's correct)

    Regarding this, sometimes the arXiv version of a paper will have updates not present in the "final publication", since authors may continue to update the arXiv version to correct typos, etc.. I believe that if a user wants the final publication, they can always go to the journal webpage and import that, if desired.

    So personally, I'd prefer to always get the 'preprint' metadata, if I save a paper from arXiv. I also think what's not right is importing the PDF from arXiv, but then pulling the metadata from the final publication. That seems inconsistent.

    > You _can_ import the 'preprint' metadata by right-clicking on the Save to Zotero icon

    Could we have an option in this menu to import it just as an arXiv preprint? I tried all the options in the menu and it either imports it as a published paper, or the full book (though in both cases the PDF is just the one coming from arXiv).
  • adamsmith
    Could we have an option in this menu to import it just as an arXiv preprint? I tried all the options in the menu and it either imports it as a published paper, or the full book (though in both cases the PDF is just the one coming from arXiv).
    Please re-read the last paragraph of my reply. I put in the effort to write a thorough explanation, please reciprocate by taking the time to read it closely so I'm not wasting my time.
  • b0c5
    edited January 11, 2024
    Sorry, I think I misunderstood this part:

    > currently that imports as a journal article because we don't handle preprints from Datacite properly, but that's something we'll actually fix, hopefully in the near future

    You're saying that the current behavior has a bug, but normally it should import as preprint? (That is, when one follows the steps you mentioned, right-clicking on the Save to Zotero icon, selecting DOI and then the chapter title)
  • adamsmith
    yup, exactly.
  • b0c5
    Ok, sorry for the misunderstanding.
Sign In or Register to comment.