Using Zotero to finish a project
This discussion was created from comments split from: Editing Bibliography.
This is an old discussion that has not been active in a long time. Before commenting here, you should strongly consider starting a new discussion instead. If you think the content of this discussion is still relevant, you can link to it from your new discussion.
Zotero is really most effective when used from the start at least of the writing, ideally of the research process for a project.
In my experience (I was finished with my first draft if my doctoral thesis --my formal proposal long complete) when Reference Manager 10 failed. Although I had backups of my documents and library, it became clear after working with tech support and learning that the product was sunsetting that my project couldn't be completed with that software. I had been using RM since it was a CP/M program. I considered switching to EndNote since it was published by the same developer but I made the decision to make a jump to Zotero.
I printed out a hard copy of my work to that point, made another electronic copy of my Word document, stripped the field codes from the copy and set to work. I already had 400+ individual items in me bibliography.
All in all, rebuilding my bib library in Zotero required 6 to 7 hours of work. Except for 15 to 20 items that had to be completely hand entered, I was able to automatically capture the other references -- journal articles and books -- by importing from the websites of publishers and bibliographic databases. That went much more quickly than I feared. Getting the book chapter entries from the book records I had imported was a bit more tedious than I thought but I discovered that the effort to insert the chapter cites into the thesis required less effort than it had been with Reference Manager. After getting the records into Zotero I had more work to do. I needed to edit all of my Zotero records to get all duplicate authors' names in the same format and all titles converted to sentence case. This process was quick and easy and required only about 2 hours.
Revising the manuscript was tedious but easy. I had a Word document file with my (no longer linked) citations. Using my printed copy and its bibliography I went through my Word doc, highlighted each citation, and inserted the live Zotero cite in its place.
The whole process was completed in a very long day and evening. But the time wasn't all lost. I was able to identify several errors. Not only were there typos and unclear phrases in my original document I identified while I re-did the references there were a couple of very serious errors that I discovered -- one of which saved me serious embarrassment and another of which was a completely wrong cite. I had already proofread the draft as finding these errors was a really good benefit.
The effort required to get material into Zotero has the added benefit of making it easier to write the manuscripts for journal article submissions.